Packing School Lunches That Don’t Come Back Half-Eaten

There is nothing quite like opening your kid’s lunchbox at 3:30 only to find the sandwich with only one bite gone, the apple bruised, and a mysterious sticky residue on everything.

As a former kindergarten teacher and a mom of two (and someone who knows a little about nutrition), I have been there too. Over time, I’ve learned a few tricks that make it way more likely that lunches actually get eaten and not just hauled back home.

Here are five things that have made a big difference for us (and might just save your sanity too):

  1. Understand the Real Issue:

???? Sometimes it’s too much food, wrong textures, or food that doesn’t travel well. 
???? Sometimes kids are too busy socializing and don’t want foods that take too much time to eat.
???? Sometimes they have trouble opening the packaging and sit at lunch with their hand raised for five minutes for someone to help.

Know that it’s not always about you being a bad packer. Sometimes they may just not feel like eating much that day. 

  1. Keep it Simple and Bite Sized:

???? Kids eat more when food is cut small and easy to grab.
???? Mini versions of things > big sandwiches.
???? Bento-style lunchboxes make food more fun and less overwhelming.

Example: grapes sliced in half, cheese cubes, turkey roll-ups.

  1. Balance Protein + Carbs + Fun

???? Think a simple nutrition framework: protein, carb, and something colorful (it doesn’t have to be fancy!) Example: deli meat, crackers, strawberries

Bonus tip: add one “fun” food (cookie, fruit snacks, etc)

  1. Get the Kids Involved

Let them pick out one fruit or veggie at the store each week. We use Instacart a lot, so they think it’s fun to use my phone to pick it out!

???? Give them two choices when packing lunch: “grapes or strawberries?”
Involvement = ownership = more likely to eat it. 

  1. Don’t Overcomplicate it

➡️ Pinterest lunches aren’t realistic for anyone
➡️ Your kid doesn’t need sandwich animals shaped with cookie cutters (unless you genuinely love doing it).
➡️ Consistency > perfection.

 

???? Liz Olson Photography
MY GO-TO LUNCHES FOR OUR KIDS RIGHT NOW (ages 5 & 8)

My 5 year old: deli turkey, strawberries, doritos, beans (we rotate between garbanzo beans – chickpeas- and black beans), yogurt, and an oreo

My 8 year old: turkey pepperoni, PBJ sandwich- cut in halves, yogurt, beans, and a hershey’s kiss

Here are a few more easy pairings you can consider:

  • Turkey roll-ups + pretzels + apple slices + string cheese
  • Mini hummus + pita bread + cucumber sticks + grapes
  • Hard-boiled egg + crackers + strawberries + dark chocolate square

At the end of the day, the goal isn’t a perfect lunchbox, it’s a fed kid. Some days they’ll eat everything, some days they won’t touch a thing. What matters is that you’re doing your best, showing up every day, and teaching your kids that food can be both nourishing and enjoyable. And, THAT matters way more than a perfectly eaten sandwich.

What’s one lunchbox combo your kids are loving right now? I’m always looking for new ideas!
Previous articleDear Transitions, Please Be Gentle
Next articleHow to Build a Life You Love When Everyone Else Still Needs You
Katy Ferguson
Katy is on a mission to squash every fitness and nutrition myth out there! As a certified nutrition coach and personal trainer, she believes in the power of fueling your body to thrive in the busyness of motherhood. Katy is a St. Louis native and a former Kindergarten teacher. Her love of fitness and nutrition runs deep – she has been in the fitness industry as an athlete for 10+ years and has owned a women’s only fitness business since 2018. As a busy mom of two littles (ages 4 & 6), she understands the struggle to find balance in life: workouts, nutrition, motherhood, relationships, social connections, and inner peace. “Let’s face it, results come from actions, not intentions. And I LOVE helping women find balance in this.” REAL change with nutrition and fitness happens when you ditch the all-or-nothing mindset. A great week for her would include: an early morning workout, a steaming hot shower, dark chocolate sea salt caramels, kisses & snuggles from her littles, a good burger, being outside, doing aerial silks, day dates with her husband, lifting weights, hiking, lazy evenings in front of the TV.